GAME HEROES BUY POLICY Updated March 2026
Please DO NOT CALL the store for ANY sales inquiries.
The ONLY point of contact for sales inquiries will be EMAIL gameheroesonline@gmail.com
TEXT (720-879-2780), or Facebook messenger facebook.com/gameheroesonline
ANY phone calls will be directed to this website for communication via text/email/facebook message
*IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER*
If you are unfamiliar with the value of any items you are trying to sell, we apologize but will ask you to go elsewhere to sell your items, we unfortunately to not have time to ‘look at’, ‘check out’, or appraise ANY items, the ONLY way we can purchase your items is if you have the items with known value separated out and ready to sell
Please be prepared to wait as we are busy at all times.
Please be aware, Game Heroes already has a massive inventory, and has very little current needs
Magic the Gathering - Trade Policy Details
We only buy the following:
NON FOIL – Most English, Revised and Newer
FOIL – We are currently NOT BUYING ANY Foil/Secret Lair cards
At this time we are not buying any bulk
Commons/Uncommons/Foils/
We are ONLY buying bulk rares
Bulk Rares/Mythics/Foils Rares
Cash = $.10 each
Store Credit = $.15 each
****WE DO NOT BUY***
ANY NON Modern FOIL CARDS, Loose Packs, ANY Foreign Cards
Any Alpha/Beta/Unlimited/Legends/Arabian Nights/Antiquities Cards
Magic sealed product
Pokemon - Buy Policy Details
NON GRADED RAW ENGLISH CARDS
The only graded cards that we are actively buying based off of market value are PSA 10s
*Any slabs that have inconsistent comps/few sales we will not buy
*Any Modern Non PSA 10 slabs are purchased at the Raw card price
Cards Ranging: $5-$199.99 TCG Player Market/Collectr: 60% Cash 70% Credit
Cards Ranging: $200-$2000 TCG Player Market/Collectr: 70% Cash 80% Credit
(Requires Manager Approval if above $500 for an individual card)
*Vintage / Older Cards are priced by condition (We will rarely grade a vintage card NM)
*The ONLY Vintage Raw cards we will buy have to be HOLO
*We WILL NOT BUY RAW Japanese Singles
*We WILL NOT BUY, promotional cards such as Pokemon Center Promos and Play Promos
*Modern Cards have to be Near mint with good centering for full rates
We will buy most sealed product at least 70% cash and 80% store credit of market, as well as a sealed product hot list which can be found on our website:
https://docs.google.com/
-Individual sealed product items going for $500 or more will require manager approval
-Cash payouts of over $1000 will require zelle/paypal/check
The Sealed Product Buylist can be found here
Bulk Rates
At this time we are not buying any bulk
Commons/Uncommons/Energy/
We are only buying bulk ULTRA RARES and Bulk Slabs
Bulk Ultra Rares (EX/GX/V/Vmax/Vstar/Gold/
Cash – $.25 each
Credit – $.35 each
Bulk Slabs
Cash – $5 each
Credit – $10 each
Sports Cards - Buy Policy Details
We only buy sports cards at off site card shows, so make sure to check us out at the next one! We apologize but cannot buy ANY sports cards in store.
Video Games - Buy Policy Details
Game Heroes purchases the following Video Game Items:
Individual Games
Handheld Consoles (Gameboy/Gameboy Advance/Nintendo Switch
Using either eBay Sold listings or PriceCharting | Price Guides for Games, Cards & Comics as a price point, we pay the following rates:
CASH = 60%
*Store Credit = 70%
*We are primarily only looking for games that are selling for $20 or more from the following IPs:
Pokemon, Zelda, Final Fantasy, Resident Evil
Games / Consoles that have inconsistent sales data or items we do not feel we can sell we may pass on
We DO NOT BUY:
Non Hand Held Consoles
Disc Only Games
Controllers
Wires
Accessories
Disney Lorcana / Star Wars Unlimited / One Piece Buy Policy
Lego - Buy Policy
We are not buying Legos at this time.